It’s no surprise that the wrong mattress can turn bedtime into a battle and leaves you restless. Poor sleep leads to groggy mornings, sore backs, and more frustration than anyone needs.
A bad mattress doesn’t just mess with your comfort, it affects your health, mood, and even your relationship. So to make sure your mood stays great and your relationship with your partner stays strong, getting a custom size mattress would be a wise choice.
A standard mattress rarely meets the unique sleep needs of two people. A custom mattress, however, allows each partner to enjoy personalized comfort and support.
Whether you choose a split mattress, or two separate mattresses, you’ll find a solution that works for both of you. Plus, companies like Orange Mattress of Clark, NJ offer factory-direct custom options, ensuring a perfect fit at a better price.
In this guide, we’re covering everything you need to know, how to choose the right size, what features to look for, where to buy, and what to watch out for when it comes to price and quality. Let’s get started with this topic.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Custom Size Mattress
We all know finding the right custom-size mattress isn’t just about picking a random measurement and calling it a day. This section is all about breaking down the key things you need to think about before ordering one, because nothing’s worse than getting a mattress that almost fits your space but doesn’t fit your sleeping needs.
We’ll talk about room size, body type, sleeping position, and even little details most people forget like whether your bed frame or doorway can actually handle it. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to look for so you don’t end up regretting your pick.
Size & Dimensions
When it comes to picking the mattress size, it’s not just about what fits in your bedroom, it’s about how much space you actually need to sleep like a normal person.
If you have ever woken up clinging to the edge of the bed while your partner, kid, or dog is sprawled out like they own the place is no fun. If you share your bed, bigger is usually better. In this case, a king size bed sounds better as it’s spacious and you can sleep comfortably.
But let’s not forget about the room itself, a king-sized bed sounds great until you realize it leaves you with just enough space to sidestep to the door.
So before you commit, grab a tape measure the space that you think is enough to be covered by a mattress and enough for you to sleep on. You don’t want your room to like a mattress showroom with no room to move, it’s better to keep size down.
Material & Comfort
If you ever wake up feeling restless, with a really worse backache, that could be your mattress’s doing. The material it’s made of plays a huge role in how comfortable you feel and how well you sleep.
Memory foam is great if you like a sink-in, slow-hug kind of bed. It’s great for pressure relief, but if you are someone who gets hot, you might wake up feeling like a baked potato.
Latex is another choice for the mattress material. It’s the bouncy, breathable, all-natural option, perfect for anyone who wants a cooler sleep and an eco-friendly vibe.
Innerspring is an old-school, sturdy kind of material. It’s super supportive but not always the best at cushioning pressure points. And hybrids, they are the best of both worlds, coils for support, foam for comfort, so you don’t have to pick sides.
Motion Isolation
When you share a bed, motion isolation matters a lot because no one wants to wake up every time their partner rolls over or gets up for a glass of water.
Memory foam is the best at keeping movement contained as it absorbs motion like a sponge, so you won’t feel much of anything on your side. Latex does a decent job too, though it has a bit more bounce.
And the hybrids with thick foam layers, they are great too, but traditional innerspring mattresses might not be a good choice. If your partner moves a lot, go for foam or a foam-heavy hybrid.
Temperature Regulation
Sweating like you just ran a marathon in your sleep isn’t a very great way of waking up. Temperature plays a huge role in sleep quality and if your mattress traps heat, you’re in for some restless nights.
Some materials like memory foam, tend to hold onto warmth, which can be the worst sleeping experience for hot sleepers. While on the other hand, latex, hybrid, and innerspring mattresses allow for better airflow, keeping things cooler, making them a better choice.
Research even shows that cooler sleep environments improve deep sleep. So if you’re someone who constantly switches pillows for the cool side, mattress choice definitely matters.
Firmness Preferences
Let’s talk about one of the biggest sleep debates out there which is mattress firmness. If you prefer your bed to feel like a fluffy marshmallow, but your partner wants something firmer than a gym mat. This is not a very ideal situation and you both might end up annoying each other.
If you and your partner have totally different sleep preferences, don’t worry, you don’t have to settle. There are split mattresses that let each of you pick your own firmness, so no one has to compromise.
You can try another option which is an adjustable base. These mattresses let you raise, lower, and make changes in different sections of the bed, perfect if one of you needs extra support.
Edge Support
Edge support is important if you have ever been in a situation where you are too close to the edge of the bed and about to take a nosedive, it is really worse. And if you sleep with a partner, solid edge support is a must.
You don’t want to feel like you’re slipping off every time they move or worse, like the whole bed is caving in. A mattress with good edge support keeps everything steady. Foam beds sometimes struggle with this, while hybrids and innersprings tend to hold up better.
If you sit on the edge a lot or share a smaller bed, you’ll notice the difference. So make sure when you choose a mattress, it has an edge support.
Additional features and accessories
Alright, let’s talk about the little extras that can make a big difference when getting a custom-size mattress. First up, mattress toppers, if you want a little extra softness or need more support, a topper can change the whole feel of your bed.
Some mattresses even have cooling features, which is great if you tend to get hot in your sleep. Then, there are custom sheets too because standard sheets might not fit, so you may need ones that are made specifically for your mattress.
A good set of deep-pocket sheets can save you from the frustration of wrestling with fabric at 2 AM. Adjustable bases are another feature that enhances your sleeping experience, especially if you like reading or watching TV in bed. If that’s not peak relaxation, I don’t know what is.
And don’t forget a waterproof protector as it keeps spills, sweat, and dust mites from ruining your mattress and keeps it in amazing condition. All these little things make your custom mattress feel even more like it was made just for you because it was.
Custom Size Mattress: Cost & Availability
A standard mattress will always be cheaper than a custom one, because it’s mass produced. A queen or king size produced and dispatched from the factory line like clockwork, keeping costs low.
But if you ask for a mattress that’s a little longer, wider, or just shaped differently, you can expect the prices to increase. Also, depending on materials and size, a custom mattress can cost anywhere from 20% to 50% more than a standard one because of all that customization which is reasonable because it’s made especially to fit you and your needs.
Now, where do you even buy one? You’ve got two main options, either you buy it from online retailers or local manufacturers. Online gives you the convenience of custom size, and it’s shipped straight to your door. But a local manufacturer, that’s where you get the real personal touches done.
You can talk to them, feel the materials, and sometimes even negotiate a better price. If you go this route, check reviews, ask about the foam density or coil count (because quality matters), and always read the warranty and return policy. Some custom mattresses are final sale, no take-backs.
If you’re going custom and willing to spend a lot, just make sure it’s worth it, no one wants to spend extra on a mattress that turns into a regret.
Conclusion
I know picking the right one can feel a bit confusing but at this point, you should have a pretty great idea of what works best for you. If you’re all about plush memory foam, need the bounce of an innerspring, or want that hybrid sweet spot, there’s something out there that fits the bill.
The trick is knowing what actually matters for both you and your partner. Consider how you sleep, how firm (or soft) you like your bed, and, most importantly, what your wallet can handle.
A high price tag doesn’t always mean better sleep, but a mattress that fits your body and habits, that’s where you will feel you made the best decision.
Take your time, test a few options if you can, and trust what feels right because at the end of the day, good sleep is non-negotiable after a hectic day of work.
